Quattro Pro was one of the most cutting edge spread sheet programs, out there. Borland gave everyone the best value, understood fast is important, and maintained simple keyboard operations for power users in a consistent manner.
- However, did you know, they popularized the "tabbed interface?"
- Maybe this is why, Microsoft resisted adding tabs to Internet Explorer for so many years.
The Lawsuit
Some have claimed that Quattro Pro was the first to use the tabbed notebook metaphor - but another spreadsheet - BoeingCalc - used tabs to multiple sheets, and allowed three dimensional references before Quattro Pro was on the market. However BoeingCalc was so slow that its multiple sheet capabilities were nearly unusable.[2][1]Quattro Pro was the subject of a major lawsuit by Lotus against Borland. Lotus argued that Quattro could not copy Lotus 1-2-3 menus (it did, by design). Borland supplied the 1-2-3 menus as an alternative because keystroke compatibility was needed in order to run macros in 1-2-3 worksheets. Borland argued that just as all cars operate in the same way, Lotus could not rationally "own" the way its program behaved. The district court ruled in favor of Lotus, but the appellate court ruled that the 1-2-3 menus were functional and not copyrightable. The case went all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court which split 4 to 4 (Justice Stevens recused himself). This left the lower court ruling intact, which was a victory for Borland. However, the broader issue of whether a company can own and protect the way its program behaves remained unresolved.
By the time the case was resolved, Borland no longer owned Quattro Pro. Borland sold the spreadsheet to Novell six months before the final decision was handed down.
Glen
